Here's a listing that shows up in MetroList a few times a month. A 1950s ranch in Carmichael, 1,500 square feet, with a permitted 600-square-foot ADU behind it that rents for $1,800. The seller wants it marketed as a 2,100-square-foot home, because that's how it feels when you live there and that's the number that makes the price per foot look right. We understand the instinct, and we know how it ends at the appraisal.

Ryan Lundquist at the Sacramento Appraisal Blog spent two posts this summer on accessory dwelling units, and both are worth your time if you own one or are thinking about buying one. The first asks a question we hear constantly: should an ADU be included in the square footage? His answer is no, and his reasons are the appraiser's reasons. The second, on the first backyard ADU sold as a standalone condo, looks at a new California law that lets an ADU be sold separately from the main house. He's writing for appraisers and agents. We want to translate both into what they mean for the seller with the Carmichael ranch — and for the buyer who wants it.

Why the Appraiser Won't Add It Up

The measuring rules appraisers follow come from ANSI, the American National Standards Institute, and they count living area that is contiguous and heated. A detached unit in the backyard is neither, as far as the main house is concerned. Lundquist notes that "Fannie Mae requires appraisers to use ANSI," which matters because conventional financing is how most Sacramento homes get bought. In his words, a 1,600-square-foot house with a 400-square-foot ADU is "a 1,600 sq ft home with something else in the backyard," not a 2,000-square-foot home.

So when a listing combines the two numbers, one of three things happens. The buyer's appraiser separates them and picks comps against the smaller house, and the value comes in under what the list price implied. The buyer's agent catches it before the offer and discounts accordingly. Or nobody catches it, and the buyer finds out at the appraisal contingency, which is the worst place to find out anything. The third is where deals fall apart.

The MLS rules agree with the appraiser, incidentally. MetroList requires listing data to be accurate, and Lundquist points out that data vendors like Realist already track ADU square footage as its own field.

What an ADU Actually Adds to the Price

None of this means the ADU is worth nothing. It means the value shows up somewhere other than the square-footage column.

An appraiser values an ADU by finding sales of homes that also had ADUs and comparing them against similar homes that didn't. That's why the answer varies so much by neighborhood. On a half-acre lot in Orangevale or Fair Oaks, where detached units and workshops are part of the landscape, there's a track record of ADU sales to lean on. On a 6,000-square-foot tract lot in Citrus Heights, a new ADU might be the first on the street, and the appraiser has to reach further for evidence. Same unit, different comps, different number.

Three things move that number more than the ADU's size:

  • Permits. A permitted, finaled ADU is a dwelling. An unpermitted conversion is a question mark the appraiser may give little or no credit for, and one a buyer's lender can flag.
  • Condition and finish. We wrote about the condition gap in Sacramento earlier this year, and it applies double to ADUs. A tired unit with a hot plate is a different asset from a finished one-bedroom with its own laundry.
  • Income. If the unit has rented, documented rent history gives an appraiser and a buyer something concrete. It can also bring in a buyer whose lender will count some of that rent toward qualifying, which widens your pool. (That's lender-specific — ask before you count on it.)

Peter spent four years as a sales manager for home builders and has hands-on construction and remodeling experience, which is useful here. Before you list, we can tell you which of those three levers is worth pulling and which isn't. Spending $15,000 to finish an ADU that already rents is usually money well spent. Spending $60,000 to permit a converted garage the month before you sell usually isn't.

Our Seller Playbook for an ADU Listing

  • Enter the ADU square footage in its own field. The main house gets the main-house number. The ADU field and the remarks carry the rest. It protects the deal at the appraisal.
  • Sell the unit as its own feature. Photograph it as a separate space: kitchen, bath, entry, and the yard between it and the house. List the year permitted, whether it has its own electrical meter or address, and current or recent rent.
  • Price against ADU comps. We pull sales with ADUs first, then bracket. Pricing off larger single-unit homes is how a listing sits for six weeks and then runs into an appraisal problem.
  • Put the permit packet in the disclosures. Final inspection card, plans if you have them, any solar or utility agreements. Buyers' lenders ask for this, and having it ready shortens escrow.
  • Decide what to do about a tenant. A lease that runs past close of escrow changes who can buy the house. An owner-occupant may want the unit empty for a parent; an investor may want the tenant to stay. We'll talk that through before the sign goes up, not after an offer comes in.

Buying a Home With an ADU

The buyer's version is shorter, and it's mostly about not paying for the wrong number.

Ask for the permit history before you fall in love with the unit. If it's permitted, the county or city will have the record. If it isn't, the practical questions are whether it can be legalized, what that costs, and whether you're comfortable owning it as-is in the meantime. California has spent several years loosening ADU rules, and the state HCD ADU handbook is the plain-English overview; Sacramento County and the City of Sacramento each run their own ADU process.

Then ask your lender two things: what square footage they'll count, and whether ADU rental income can help you qualify. Some conventional and FHA programs allow it with documentation. Some don't. Get the answer in writing early.

And know that your property taxes will follow the assessed value of the whole property, main house and ADU together, reset at your purchase price. The assessor doesn't care how the MLS listed the square footage.

The Backyard-Condo Question

Lundquist's second post covers a genuinely new wrinkle. AB 1033 lets a California city opt in to allowing an ADU to be sold separately from the main house by converting the whole lot into a condo. The first such sale he found closed in San Jose in June 2026: a 749-square-foot ADU built in 2024, sold for $530,000 with conventional financing. Similar-sized detached houses in that ZIP were selling around $700,000, so the ADU-condo landed, in his description, "toward the lower end of the competitive range."

The part sellers should read twice is what happened to the main house. That property sold for $900,000 in late 2020. After the ADU went in, the owner tried to sell the whole thing for $1,390,000 and couldn't. It later came back on as a condo at $868,000. Lundquist's read: "the pool of buyers is now smaller for a main home," because the buyer is now buying a condo interest with a shared-ownership agreement attached, and financing follows condo rules.

Locally, this is a West Sacramento story for now. Per Lundquist, it's the only city in the region that has adopted AB 1033, alongside a short statewide list that includes San Jose, San Diego, Berkeley, Oakland, San Francisco, and Santa Monica. If you own a West Sac home with an ADU, you have an option most owners don't. Our advice is to treat it as an option rather than a windfall. You'd be creating two smaller, harder-to-finance properties out of one that's easy to finance, taking on the insurance, maintenance, and shared-access questions his readers raised in the comments, and doing it in a market with almost no local sales to price against. For a few owners in the right spot, that will pencil. For most, an ADU is worth more attached to the house than split from it.

ADU Questions We Hear Most

Does an ADU count toward square footage in Sacramento? Not for appraisal purposes. Appraisers using the ANSI standard measure the main house and report the ADU separately. MetroList has a separate field for it, and that's where it belongs.

How much value does an ADU add to a home in Sacramento? It depends on permits, condition, and how many nearby sales had ADUs. A permitted, finished, rentable unit in a neighborhood with ADU comps adds real value. An unpermitted conversion may add little. There's no fixed per-foot rule.

Can I sell my ADU separately from my house? Only if your city has adopted AB 1033 and you complete a condo conversion of the lot. In the Sacramento region, West Sacramento is the only adopter as of late summer 2026.

Will a lender count my ADU's rent when I buy? Some loan programs allow ADU rental income toward qualification with documentation, and some don't. Ask your lender before you write an offer.

The Bottom Line

Lundquist's point in both posts is that accurate data makes for better comps, and better comps make for better values. Our point is the seller's version: the ADU is an asset, and the way to get paid for it is to present it as exactly what it is. Separate the square footage, prove the permits, document the rent, price against the right sales. Buyers pay for clarity, and appraisers reward it.

If you're weighing whether to build one, finish one, or sell a home that already has one, that's a conversation we're glad to have in person — and we'll bring the construction experience with us.

Own a home with an ADU, or shopping for one? Search Sacramento homes for sale, get a real home valuation that accounts for the unit, or contact us.

Or call us directly: (916) 739-2424

The Peter Parker Team | DRE# 01257844 | eXp Realty DRE# 01878277
Appraisal and AB 1033 details referenced from the Sacramento Appraisal Blog (August 12 and 19, 2026) and are approximate as of late summer 2026. Permit, tax, and lending rules vary by jurisdiction and lender; this is general information, not legal, tax, or financial advice.