Last spring an appraiser stood in the kitchen of a Fair Oaks listing we had under contract and asked the seller when the roof was done. The seller thought it was 2019, or maybe 2017. The invoice was in a box somewhere. The appraiser wrote "roof appears updated" and moved on, because the old form had nowhere to put a year even if he had one. That is the sentence that just went away.
On November 5, Ryan Lundquist published "Freaking out over the new appraisal forms" on the Sacramento Appraisal Blog. It is written for appraisers and agents, and most of it is about how much more work the new report is for the person filling it out. We want to cover the part he leaves to us: what you will notice if you are buying or selling a house in the Sacramento region over the next year, and what to do about it.
What Changed, in Two Paragraphs
The forms appraisers use for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac loans are being replaced. The four familiar forms (the 1004 for houses, the 1073 for condos, the 1025 for two-to-four units, and the 2055 exterior-only report) collapse into one form under a standard called UAD 3.6. Lundquist's plain summary: "Appraisal forms have been redesigned, and there are some massive changes." A colleague he quotes, Joe Lynch, puts a number on it. The old report ran roughly 190 data points. The new one can run more than 900.
The official start date was November 2. In practice, Fannie Mae has granted a temporary exception because not every lender and software vendor is ready, and the hard deadline will be set sometime in 2027. FHA has adopted the form without a date. VA and USDA are still to be determined. So for the rest of this winter, which form shows up in your transaction depends on your lender. Ask. And none of this touches a private appraisal you order yourself for a divorce, an estate, or a pre-listing check; that work stays on the appraiser's own format.
If You Are Buying This Winter
Your appraisal contingency may need more room. The standard California purchase contract defaults to 17 days for the appraisal contingency. With appraisers inspecting longer and filling in several hundred more fields, Lundquist and the appraisers he quotes expect turn times to stretch while everyone learns the new report. Our playbook on a Fannie or Freddie loan with a lender that has already switched: write 21 days, and ask the lender on day one whether the appraisal has been ordered. A buyer who has to request an extension in week three is negotiating from weakness over something that was predictable.
The fee may go up. Nobody in the post names a dollar figure, and we will not invent one. Lynch's advice is to "expect the cost of an appraisal to rise." Another appraiser quoted, Gary Kristensen, is "optimistic neither will change dramatically." Budget for a somewhat higher appraisal fee in your closing costs and treat anything less as a pleasant surprise. If you are working through our first-time buyer guide, this is a line item to pad.
The report will be easier to read, once you know where to look. The new form opens with a summary page, puts photos next to the section they support, and gives each comparable sale its own photo in the grid. For a buyer who has only ever flipped to the value on page two, this is an improvement. Read the first page. If the appraiser rated the kitchen below the comps, you will see it, and so will your lender.
It is still an opinion. Lundquist says the biggest misconception he hears is that appraisers "are now using facts and data instead of an opinion." The new form asks for more facts; the value is still a judgment built from comparable sales. If the house you are buying appraises low, the conversation with the seller is the same conversation it was in October. Nothing about the form changes what the market will pay.
If You Are Selling: Build the List Now
This is where the new form reaches past appraisers and lands on your kitchen counter.
The old report could say "updated" and leave it there. The new one asks for an estimated roof age. It asks about converted areas and finished space that is not connected to the main house. It rates the kitchen, the bathrooms, and the bedrooms individually for quality and condition. It assigns an exterior condition rating and wants comments on the walls, the foundation, the roof, and the windows. It has real fields for an accessory dwelling unit, which used to be, in Lundquist's words, "literally one check box."
So the single most useful thing a seller can do before listing is write down every improvement with a year, a rough cost, and a source: receipt, permit, or memory. Roof, HVAC, water heater, windows, kitchen, baths, electrical panel, sewer line, solar and whether it is owned or leased. Both Lundquist and Lynch ask agents to post that list to the MLS. We go one step further. The sheet goes in the MLS remarks and a printed copy sits on the counter the day the appraiser comes, with the permits clipped to it. An appraiser with 900 fields to fill is going to be grateful, and a grateful appraiser working from documentation is less likely to guess conservatively.
Two things follow from room-by-room ratings. First, a half-renovated house is now scored as a half-renovated house. A 2024 kitchen does not lift a 1986 hall bath the way a single "updated" checkbox used to. The condition gap we wrote about in June, where updated homes pull away from dated ones, gets measured more precisely from here on. Second, the fixes with the best appraisal return are the ones that move a rating: the tired bathroom, the original windows, the roof that is fine but looks tired from the street. Our seller guide covers the order we would do them in.
And if you have an ADU or a converted garage, the form now has a place to record it properly. We covered what an ADU is really worth when you sell in September; the short version is that documentation and permits decide whether that space counts, and the new form makes that distinction harder to blur.
Where This Bites Hardest Around Sacramento
Regional rules land differently street to street, and the new fields line up closely with the quirks of our older east-county housing stock.
In Fair Oaks, Carmichael, and Orangevale, a large share of what we sell is 1960s and 1970s ranch homes with additions, enclosed patios, and converted garages, often done by a previous owner without paperwork. "Converted area" and "noncontiguous finished area" are now their own line items. If your listing counts that family room in the square footage and the appraiser cannot find a permit, expect the report to say so in a field a lender will read, not a sentence a lender might skip. Pull your permit history from the county before you list. It costs nothing and it settles the argument early.
In Citrus Heights and other entry-tier markets, the issue is usually deferred maintenance rather than additions. An exterior condition rating with specific comments on the roof and windows means a buyer's lender sees exactly what the buyer saw from the curb. Sellers there should price to the condition the form will record.
In Folsom and El Dorado Hills, where so much of the inventory is newer tract construction, we expect fewer surprises. The roof age is on a plan, the layout is standard, the permits exist. The fields that matter more are the amenity and impact ratings: a view lot, a pool, a Mello-Roos assessment, each one now flagged as positive, negative, or neutral for value and marketability.
In Midtown, condo buyers will see the same form their house-buying friends see, because the separate condo report is gone. That is a convenience for buyers comparing a condo to a small house, and it means condo sellers get the same room-by-room treatment.
One Footnote Worth Knowing
Lundquist flags one piece of the new certification language, number 25, which gives "secondary market participants" and data-collection services rights to use the appraisal data. He says he is "personally concerned." From a homeowner's seat, the practical meaning is that a detailed, structured record of your house, down to the condition of each room and the age of the roof, now exists in a lender-side dataset once you finance or sell with a conforming loan. That is not a reason to avoid the process. It is a reason to make sure the record is accurate, which brings us back to the list.
The Bottom Line
The appraiser's job did not change. As Lindsay Cappelletti, another appraiser Lundquist quotes, puts it, "the way appraisers appraise a property isn't changing, the way we report those results is what is changing." What changed is how much of your house gets written down, and how precisely. Buyers should budget a little more time and a little more money for the appraisal and read the first page when it arrives. Sellers should document everything with a date before the sign goes in the yard. His ten-changes walkthrough is worth ten minutes if you want to see the form itself, and Lundquist's post is the best plain-English explanation of the rollout we have read. For the official version, Fannie Mae's UAD page has the specification.
Rates, meanwhile, are doing what they were doing: the 30-year fixed sat at 7.24% in Freddie Mac's weekly survey at the end of October, and a buyer paying that is going to read the condition ratings closely. Give them something good to read.
Selling this winter? Get a valuation and we will build the improvements-and-dates sheet with you before an appraiser is ever ordered. Buyers, search Sacramento homes for sale and ask us which lenders in a given deal have already moved to the new form. Or contact us with a question about an appraisal you have in hand.
Or call us directly: (916) 739-2424
The Peter Parker Team | DRE# 01257844 | eXp Realty DRE# 01878277
Appraisal-form details are drawn from the Sacramento Appraisal Blog (Nov. 5, 2026) and are subject to change as Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, FHA, VA, and USDA finalize their timelines. Rate data from Freddie Mac as of late October 2026. This is general information, not financial, legal, or appraisal advice.